Making Connections

Everything starts out great, the trail has been plowed and salted.

In yesterday’s post I discussed how our currently incomplete network of bicycle facilities and transit routes are a huge barrier that keep average people, (not “cyclists”) from using bicycles for transportation and taking transit instead of driving.  Don’t get me wrong, Milwaukee and many other communities are slowly building more bicycle facilities and filling in the gaps in the network of “complete streets.”  But as it stands right now, it takes a leap of faith, a bit of research and an intrepid personality to try riding a bicycle or the bus.  Until it becomes obvious, attractive and convenient for people to use alternative modes of transportation, it will never be mainstream.

Lets imagine a person wants to try biking to work.  The person has heard a lot about the Hank Aaron State Trail, takes the trouble to get a trail map to find out where the trail is. Looking at the map it appears that the trail is really close to this person’s office and  home, perfect! It looks like the trail might be just the thing for a new bike commuter: a convenient and pleasant route away from busy traffic.

The photographs included here illustrate what that new bicycle commuter might experience.  As you can see in the photo above, someone has plowed the trail. The clear path is only about 4ft wide, but given 20 inches of snow just dumped on Milwaukee, it is pretty great that there is a path cleared on the trail at all. After all, even the major roads are a lot narrower these days since the snow has piled up along the curbs.

A week after the blizzard, the City is still working to clear the huge amount of snow that fell on Milwaukee. It really is a daunting job, but at least they have narrow path cleared on the trail.

When lots of snow falls on a city, finding a place to put it is a real problem.  In any major snow clearing operation, the first priority in most US cities is to clear a path for cars on the major arterials.  This typically means pushing the snow toward the curb, making it even more difficult for pedestrians.  Prioritizing cars over pedestrians (and even people with disabilities) is a conscious choice we have made as a society.  In many european cities, they prioritize snow clearing for the most vulnerable road users first: walkways are cleared for pedestrians, then trails and cycletracks for bicyclists, and finally the roads for motor vehicles.  There is some overlap because different equipment is used for different operations, but in general, people come before cars.

Someone walking a well-worn desire line path. Clearly a missed opportunity where someone should have built a formal connection.

The Hank Aaron State Trail functions as a sidewalk for much of the length in the Menomonee Valley.  As a sidewalk, it is he responsibility of adjoining property owners to clear the snow, just like it is for homeowners on neighborhood streets.  But a trail is a continuous path and trail users need the whole thing to be clear of snow.  If 90 percent is clear, but even 10% of the trail is still snow-covered, the entire system breaks down and it ceases to be a useful transportation corridor.

You can ram your bike through the piles of snow drift at the curb ramps or lift your bike over the piles, but the snow makes the trail inaccessible to people with disabilities, not cool or legal.

 Plowing snow from the streets to the curb leaves hard-packed piles of snow at all the curb ramps, which are a transition zone from the sidewalk or trail to the crosswalks in the roadway.  Even when crews in small plows come back to bust open the curb ramps, the frozen and compacted snow is difficult to clear from the ramp area.  This is again a result of our conscious choice as a society to prioritize cars over people.  The plow operators don’t care if they are plowing streets, sidewalks of trails.  They get paid to plow snow and just do what we tell them to do.

There are patches of glare ice where puddles have formed in low spots on the trail. That never happens on the road.

All along the Hank Aaron State Trail there are low spots where water ponds.  This is not a big deal in the warmer months, but it causes a problem in the winter.  The puddles freeze and are real hazards to people riding bicycles.  In fact, for the last three years running I have taken a spill on the Hank Aaron Trail because of these patches of black ice.  I have not been hurt because I am wary of a fall.  I actually use my annual early winter fall as my personal warning to switch to studded tires.  These low spots would never be tolerated on a road project.  A few of the worst spots have been repaired on the trail, but many still exist. 

The biggest problem with expecting the various businesses and land owners along the trail to keep it clear of snow is that as a society we have a high degree of tolerance for those who fail to comply with their responsibility.  In the same way many homeowners don’t clear their sidewalks or do a poor job of it, some land owners along the trail never clear the snow and some others do a crummy job.   Although in the end it is the responsibility of the WDNR to maintain the trail, we can’t blame them if we as taxpayers fail to allocate a snow clearing budget or provide them any equipment to do the job with salaried staff.  I am sure the trail manager would love to have the money to pay the City or County to clear the trail.  Or better yet, to have a pick-up with a plow and a staff person to do the work.  But we have cut their budget to the point they can barely pull weeds.

End of the line, for some inexplicable reason, the plow just stopped here.

In the end, this is what you get.  Somebody stops plowing at their property line and the rest of the trail remains impassable.  How can we expect to get more people biking to work or even experienced bicycle commuters to use the trail if it is not usable?  I’m using snow clearing on the Hank Aaron State Trail to make the point about how important these little connections are, but it is in no way unique.  I could have just as easily made my point by looking at someone trying to ride across the City of Milwaukee’s bike lane network during the spring or Milwaukee County’s Oak Leaf Trail system.   Again, the answer is not to blame the WDNR, the City, the County  or even the land owners.  The answer is to change our priorities as a society.  Until we make a conscious choice to priorities getting around on foot, by bicycle or in transit, those will always remain “alternative” forms of transportation.

Right now all we can do is tell our elected representatives that these things are important to us. The more politicians hear about such things, the more likely they will be to allocate resources toward them. Until those of us who care about such things get organized and speak with a unified voice, our auto-centric world will remain the status quo.  As I said in yesterday’s post, I am going to take a look at this issue from a number of angles over the next week or two.  I plan on comparing cities that have instituted change.  I want to look at the existing advocacy groups like the League of American Bicyclists to the Bicycle Federation of Wisconsin down to the fledgling local coalitions like the Bicycle Alliance of Waukesha. Do we need a new coalition to advocate for a more balanced transportation system in Milwaukee?  My hope is that through our discussions here and the Over the Bars Ride Series beginning this spring, like minded people will be able to make meaningful  and lasting connections and a coalition for change will evolve organically.


About daveschlabowske

Cyclechic advocate from Milwaukee
This entry was posted in Advocacy, Bike facilities, bike winter, commuting and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Making Connections

  1. Sonia says:

    As you mentioned, snow-clearing policies have a huge impact on pedestrians, too. I had to take my toddler to the doctor on Friday in the stroller. I only had to push him about 6 blocks…but what a long 6 blocks those were!

    It was a real eye-opener for me. I was very grateful that I do not have to be in a wheelchair because most of the sidewalk ramps would have been impassable in a wheelchair. I had to heave the stroller up and over the mounds of snow that were not adequately cleared.

    Ironically, the property owned by the City of Waukesha was the worst, in terms of snow removal. So much for the public interest…

    • daveschlabowske says:

      Again, this is generally a case of priorities. Those of us who care about such things need to tell our elected representatives that we value investments in active transportation. You folks out at the Waukesha Bicycle Alliance are on the right track and doing great work. We all have a long way to go of course, but I see improvement every day. Thanks for what you are doing “out west.”

  2. John says:

    Your photo titled, “Well worn desire line path” is the Missing Link that I waited for over a year after the sewer work and Canal Street Bridge were completed here for the city to build a side walk connection from the west end of Greeves Street up to the west end of the Canal Street bridge east of 32nd Street. I and others were riding and walking on the steep grassy slope on this route for the that first year which was starting to badly erode after rains. So, I decided, JUST DO IT, meaning building a good trail myself with a fairly even grade by cutting a benchcut into the hillside where needed and building it so that erosion would be controlled. It took 10 full days of work to complete this short missing link.

    • daveschlabowske says:

      Thanks for the work John. When I reviewed the 60% plans for the new Canal Street Bridge and the Hank Aaron State Trail, I told the designers that if they did not put an official connection at that location, there would be a desire line trail worn in the hill as soon as they open the street. That was one battle I just didn’t win. I also made the comment that the entire extension should be connected to every dead-end street that it passed and have additional connections near every major road. But the project was already over budget so they could only add a couple of the neighborhood connections I suggested. I actually went so far as to say they shouldn’t build the bridge over Hawley and instead use that money to make sure the trail connected to every road it could, including 84th street, which has a high grade separation. I argued that it is only difficult to cross Hawley at peak hours and a center refuge island would make it passable even then. I suggested they seek highway safety funds or enhancement funds later for a bridge if that crossing proved a real problem. That was another argument I did not win. In the end, the bridge is very nice, but I think the trail would get more use if it had more connections.

      The other really missing connection is into State Fair Park. That was not a fault of the designers or the WDNR, it was more that the fairpark people were worried about how they would have to staff an additional gate during the State Fair.

  3. Dave Steele says:

    When a huge blizzard hits like the one last week, it really illustrates exactly where society’s priorities lie.

    As a non-driver, by choice, the aftermath of the blizzard sent a message that I will not soon forget. The message wasn’t that we don’t matter as much as car drivers – we knew that already. The message was that my ability to safely be a pedestrian barely even registers as a priority. It’s an afterthought.

    The message was, essentially: first we will make things safe for car drivers. Then we will make things convenient for car drivers. Then, after we have made things totally normal for car drivers, we will get around to make things safe and accessible for non-car drivers.

    In other words, the convenience of one group of people is more important than the safety of another group of people.

    I’m not necessarily complaining, because I know that complaining would be fruitless. Sure, I could call my alderman and demand that the crosswalk on my block be cleared out, but that’s not going to change the fundamental dynamic.

    In a world where virtually everyone drives, those that don’t drive virtually don’t exist.

    • daveschlabowske says:

      That is true, and curious since we are all pedestrians. Every trip, whether you make it in a car, on a bus or on a bike, includes walking. Yet it is the lowest priority in our transportation system.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s